Craftsman
The Craftsman 16 Gallon Wet/Dry Shop Vac combines powerful 6.5 peak HP performance with versatile functionality for demanding cleanup tasks. Its polypropylene construction offers practical durability while the oversized drain facilitates quick liquid disposal. The dual-flex hose technology prevents kinking during operation, and the built-in blower port adds versatility for outdoor debris management. Comes complete with essential attachments for tackling diverse cleaning challenges in garage, workshop, and jobsite environments.
The Craftsman shop vac (6.5/10) embodies the decline of a once-legendary BIFL brand. Its powerful 6.5HP motor remains impressive, but cheaper plastics and quality control issues plague newer models. It's serviceable with common parts, though finding exact replacements for legacy models is frustrating. Best for occasional home users who prioritize suction power over build quality and don't mind replacing components every few years. The 3-year warranty is adequate but pales compared to Ridgid's lifetime coverage. A capable tool that will serve you well, but don't expect the multi-decade lifespan of vintage Craftsman vacs.
Serviceable with common replacement parts, but some quality concerns in newer models.
Bottom line: Basic repairs are straightforward with standard tools, but finding exact replacement parts for legacy models is frustrating. The simple design makes motor access easy, but declining component quality means more frequent repairs needed.
A tale of two vacs: powerful motor meets questionable plastics. Many users report replacing 20-30 year old Craftsman vacs, suggesting potential for longevity, but newer models show concerning quality control issues.
Bottom line: The core vacuum will likely outlast its cheaper plastic components by years, making it durable but not truly BIFL like its predecessors.
Craftsman offers a 3-year limited warranty on this shop vac that covers defects in materials and workmanship, but excludes normal wear items like filters and accessories.
Bottom line: The 3-year warranty provides moderate protection for a tool in this category, but lacks the exceptional coverage found in premium brands like Ridgid that offer lifetime warranties on similar products.
Craftsman shop vacs spark passionate debates on Reddit between old-timer loyalists and frustrated modern buyers. The brand rides on legendary 30-40 year lifespans of Sears-era models, but newer units face scrutiny.
Bottom line: Redditors trust vintage Craftsman as BIFL gold but approach new models with caution - strong suction power can't fully overcome quality control concerns and parts availability headaches.
Based on 199 reviews
We rate products using a 10-point scoring system focused on what matters most: durability, reliability, and repairability. Our scores are built from a wide net of sources: Amazon reviews, Reddit threads, expert opinions, brand sites, Google reviews, and what people are actually saying online.
Powerful 6.5HP motor handles everything
Many users report decades-long lifespans
Simple design allows easy motor access
Strong suction for various materials
Cheap plastic components break easily
Replacement filters often don't fit
Quality control issues with newer models
Only 3-year warranty versus competitors
Based on our comprehensive product research and scoring methodology
Main product view
Recommended: As Needed / Weekly•Inspect and empty after every use; perform deeper cleaning and filter maintenance weekly or as needed, especially after heavy use or picking up liquids.
Empty the drum immediately after each use and rinse it with water to remove debris and prevent odors[3]. Clean the hose and attachments with water, and remove any clogs. For the exterior, wipe with a damp cloth and mild soap; avoid harsh chemicals[9].
Recommended Products
Dry the filter completely before storing or picking up dry debris to prevent mold and maintain suction[1][8]. Inspect the filter for tears and replace if damaged; use a HEPA-rated filter for fine dust if needed[1]. Check the float mechanism and hose connections for proper function.
Recommended Products
Store the vac in a dry, cool place with the drum and accessories completely dry to prevent rust and mildew. Use on-board hose and cord organizers for neat storage and to protect hoses from kinking[4]. Keep the filter detached if storing long-term after liquid pickups.
Sign up for the BIFL Bi-Monthly
This site is for you. Help us make it better. We're constantly refining the way we score and present BIFL products. If something's missing, broken, or off — we want to hear from you.
