by Frieling Goliath Natural Mortar and Pestle Spice Grinder

This granite mortar and pestle is naturally repairable through basic maintenance rather than component replacement.

• •Material durability: Solid granite construction means the bowl itself rarely fails under normal use - users report 5+ years of heavy usage with it looking brand new.
• •Pestle vulnerability: Multiple reports of the pestle breaking in half, sometimes during normal use making guacamole, suggesting a potential structural weakness.
• •User serviceability: No complex mechanisms or parts to replace, but simple reconditioning possible by re-roughening the grinding surface if it smooths over time.

Bottom line: A naturally durable tool that can last generations when intact, but inconsistent quality control with the pestle is concerning. Get a replacement if it breaks, as there's nothing to fix when solid stone fails.

A tale of two pestle experiences. When users get an undamaged unit, they rave about a tool that could last generations. But an alarming number report pestles arriving broken or breaking during normal use - a shocking failure for a solid granite tool.

• •Material integrity issues: Multiple reports of pestles breaking in half during shipping or normal use. One user's pestle broke making guacamole after just 6 uses.
• •Quality control problems: Many units arrive with chemical smells, waxy coatings, or excessive granite dust that contaminates food.
• •Design strength: Intact units receive praise for their weight, stability, and grinding efficiency. Users who get good ones report years of heavy use with no visible wear.

Bottom line: When it works, it's fantastic, but severe manufacturing inconsistencies make this a risky buy. The granite itself should last decades, but design flaws in the pestle create a critical failure point.

The Cilio by Frieling Goliath Natural Granite Mortar and Pestle has no manufacturer warranty coverage whatsoever.

• •No Protection: No warranty terms are offered with this product, leaving consumers with no recourse for manufacturing defects.
• •Quality Issues: Multiple user reports of pestles arriving broken or breaking during normal use indicate potential structural weaknesses.
• •Return Process: While there is a return/damage claim process via Frieling customer service, this is merely standard retail policy, not warranty coverage.

Bottom line: This product offers zero warranty protection despite its premium price point and BIFL positioning, forcing consumers to assume all risk for defects after the standard return window closes.

This Cilio granite mortar has wildly polarized reviews with no middle ground. Users who get an intact unit say it's absolutely worth the money as a lifetime tool, while many others report pestles arriving broken or products reeking of petroleum.

• •Quality lottery: Multiple reviewers mention pestles breaking during shipping or even during normal use making guacamole, suggesting serious packaging or material issues
• •Chemical concerns: Significant reports of strong gasoline smells and sticky coatings raise major food safety red flags that would horrify the BIFL crowd
• •When it works: Those lucky enough to get a good unit praise the heavy granite that stays planted while grinding and the coarse interior that makes quick work of spices

Bottom line: Classic case of great product ruined by terrible quality control - the lack of warranty makes this Russian roulette purchase even riskier for BIFL standards.