Mixed signals from the community. Amazon reviewers appreciate the high-carbon steel quality and comprehensive variety, but report serious quality control issues including brittle smaller files that snap during normal use and a flimsy storage case that self-destructs. Reddit's BIFL community values durability above all else, and these reports of files breaking on soft materials like plastic would raise red flags.
- •Praise pattern: Users love the steel quality with one saying the files are durable and wear-resistant even on metals, plus the comfortable rubber handles prevent blisters
- •Major concern: Multiple reports of smaller files snapping in two on basic use, with one user saying it broke almost immediately on plastic
- •Storage complaints: The included case is universally panned - files sliding in and out actually destroy the elastic and fabric
Bottom line: At $26, it's decent for light hobby use, but the brittle smaller files and poor quality control mean it's not true BIFL material that Redditors would recommend.