Metal Leaf Rake

The Fiskars Metal Leaf Rake has known failure points but can be repaired with some DIY solutions.

• •Weak connection point: Multiple users report the head-to-handle connection fails, but one user successfully reinforced it with 5-6 additional screws as a DIY fix.
• •Parts availability: The plastic rake head breaks eventually according to repeat buyers, but warranty replacements are mentioned, though with inconsistent experiences.
• •Tool requirements: Simple repairs require basic tools (screwdriver), while reinforcement modifications need basic drilling/fastening skills.

Bottom line: Not truly BIFL, but fixable with modest skills. The most common failure (head-handle connection) can be prevented with a DIY reinforcement, though the plastic head will eventually need replacement when it cracks.

This rake is a paradox — users call it the best rake ever while admitting it breaks predictably. The plastic head WILL crack, the screw WILL fall out, and the aluminum handle WILL bend, yet people keep buying replacements because it works that well.

• •Known failure points: Users report the head mount to handle is inadequate, plastic head cracks or snaps under load, and lightweight aluminum handle is prone to bending permanently
• •Warranty reality check: Despite lifetime warranty claims, one user called it a gimmick after reading exclusions for normal wear and tear, plus you pay shipping both ways
• •Die-hard fans work around flaws: One owner reinforced the head with 5-6 additional screws, another said it's a testament to the rake that I keep coming back after breaking 2

Bottom line: Amazing performance trapped in a mediocre build. If you're gentle and willing to DIY reinforce it, you'll love it. If you want true BIFL durability, keep looking.

Fiskars offers a lifetime warranty on their Metal Leaf Rake, but it comes with significant limitations and has mixed implementation results.

• •Coverage Terms: The "lifetime warranty" covers defects in materials and workmanship for as long as the consumer owns the product, but specifically excludes normal wear and tear.
• •Claim Process: Customer must submit a claim form, provide proof of purchase, product photos, and ship the product back at their expense, which can be costly for large items like rakes.
• •Real-world Experience: User experiences vary widely - some report successful free replacements, while others call it a "gimmick" due to extensive exclusions and shipping costs that make claims impractical for lower-cost items.

Bottom line: The warranty terms are generous on paper, but the user-paid return shipping requirement and broad exclusions create practical barriers. Still, numerous reports confirm Fiskars does honor valid claims, often with minimal hassle beyond shipping costs.

The Fiskars Metal Leaf Rake has a split reputation in the BIFL community. Users consistently praise its lightweight design and exceptional performance, but durability issues prevent it from being a true BIFL recommendation.

• •Performance praise: Many users call it the best rake they've ever used, noting its lightweight design reduces back strain and the tines effectively grab leaves without clogging.
• •Reliability concerns: Common failure points include the head-to-handle connection breaking, plastic head cracking, and aluminum handle bending. Many users report buying multiple replacements.
• •Warranty issues: Fiskars' warranty appears inconsistent, with some users getting replacements while others cite exclusions making it difficult to claim.

Bottom line: Redditors consistently buy this rake again despite known durability issues because it works so exceptionally well. It's loved for performance but not longevity.