The Nitecore P12 looks like a bombproof tactical flashlight initially, but long-term reliability issues make it a questionable BIFL candidate. Many users report electronic failures within 6-18 months of use, particularly with the mode button and internal circuitry.
- •Build quality: Solid aluminum construction with good waterproofing and included spare parts (O-rings, tail cap button) suggest maintenance-friendly design.
- •Failure patterns: Concerning reports of complete failures or getting stuck in lowest brightness mode after 6-18 months, even with light use. Internal components appear fragile despite robust exterior.
- •Heat management: Extreme heat on turbo mode raises concerns about long-term component damage, possibly contributing to premature failures.
Bottom line: Could've been great, but the recurring electronic failures put this in the 4-6 year category at best, and that's if you're lucky. Not true BIFL material despite the promising exterior.