Coleman tents generate mixed reactions across Reddit communities, with the Red Canyon model following typical Coleman patterns. Users acknowledge getting years of use from these tents but frequently report pole failures and weather resistance issues.
- •Durability concerns: Multiple reports of fiberglass poles snapping or splintering even during setup, with one user's Montana 8 pole cracking on first use
- •Replacement part frustration: Users struggle to find poles and rainflys for discontinued models like the Red Canyon, with one offering bounties on r/GearTrade for missing awning poles
- •You get what you pay for sentiment: Redditors often defend Coleman for casual fair-weather camping but warn against expecting Marmot-level performance at budget prices
Bottom line: While some users report 10+ years of service, the community consensus is that Coleman offers acceptable entry-level value but shouldn't be trusted for serious weather or long-term reliability without expecting component failures.